Suggestions Regarding the Map

I believe the two biggest barriers to getting infinite worlds are, first, that TFP has no plans to create additional biomes. This game has five biomes. That's it. Five biomes will never be enough variety to make an infinite world work well. Before pushing for infinite worlds, you have to first change TFP's mind about limiting the world to five biomes and good luck with that.

The second obstacle is consoles not being able to run a stable infinite world ever. That's the reality and that is where this dream dies. Sorry for the reality check.

But....if you can convince TFP to double the number of biomes and develop a major exclusive feature for PC that consoles can't have after TFP suffered through years of reading complaints from customers of the Telltale version that their version was different from PC, then maybe you've got a shot.
 
Last edited:
Five biomes will never be enough variety to make an infinite world work well.
I don't see how these are related? Any amount of biomes would necessarily repeat on an infinite map. From the other direction, any map can be colored with 4 colors such that no two neighbors get the same color; so even if you'd necessitate that the map must have some specific features, the 5th is extra. And would "doubling" change a thing?

What am I missing?
 
I don't see how these are related? Any amount of biomes would necessarily repeat on an infinite map. From the other direction, any map can be colored with 4 colors such that no two neighbors get the same color; so even if you'd necessitate that the map must have some specific features, the 5th is extra. And would "doubling" change a thing?

What am I missing?
Maybe nothing. Could be different biomes with unique features are uninteresting to you. In my opinion, it is what makes Minecraft's infinitely generated world work so well. Yes, you would still have repetition but you would have to travel farther in order to experience that repetition. With 10 biomes or more on our current largest map size the biomes would have to be much smaller area-wise. But with 10 or more biomes at the current biome size for the largest current map size we would need a much larger map aka infinitely generated in order to fit them all in. Plus you could play an entire game and not ever see 1-2 of the biomes because of the direction you chose to travel but then in a following playthrough you might find those biomes.

Swamp (one block deep water everywhere with sleepers)
Plains
Flooded City (First 1-2 stories of buildings under water)
Cavernous (Cave networks abound here)
Maple Forest (split the current forest into this and the following)
Pine Forest
Burnt Forest
Desert
Mesa (more mountainous and colorful with deep canyons and tall mesas)
Wasteland
Snow

Yes, those would repeat on an infinite map for people traveling 20km but they would have to travel 20km to find them. And maybe the flooded city and cavernous biomes are rare so they have to be found and repeat much less often if at all.
 
Last edited:
Could be different biomes with unique features are uninteresting to you.
You were presenting it as a blocking issue to implementing infinite worlds; this has very little to do with my interests, or yours. As a thought experiment, could we produce an infinite world of just forest biome? Obviously yes. Variance would obviously come from something else; but it could still make for great feeling worlds, especially if the world gen properly supported it: see a river, and you can follow it wherever it leads, be it mountains upstream, or a lake downstream.
 
I’ve used Nitrogen’s maps, and they are indeed better generated than TFP’s, but there aren’t enough rivers and lakes. This is probably due to the map size; if I were to add a large number of rivers and lakes, it would reduce the amount of land.
Post automatically merged:


I assume you’ve seen the A15 wilderness layout above; I want to achieve that kind of effect—huge lakes and rivers. And I want to be able to trace the rivers
Yes, I have played A15 and the prior 8, So I got to experience the changes as they happened.
Archived almost each of the versions 82 vanilla so far, and 30 modded from then until now and play
Round robin going through them to get Ideas for personal changes.

As @Riamus posted Teragon can make the rivers and lakes also, I use it with a map I created to fine tune
the details of the terrain, once I have my layout as I like.

The reason I referred to Nitrogen is because, of what you posted as your desire, and the pictures you
presented. The way for you to get closer to what you want, is through personal customization. Starting
at the terrain, you would need to use an image editor to adjust the grayscale, that will give the elevation
differences. Then for the large waterways and bodies of water, you would have to drop the grayscale
below a specific height, and the game will auto populate, it with water. They never removed the ability
people just stopped using it as much. For mountains, to get erosion effects there are two main ways that
I have seen so far. Get a geo height map, Or I then would defer to Teragon. But the more custom and away
form the default, the more caveates you must be willing to accept. Meaning, the more tris details on the
top landform, the more you have to adjust your own setting to balance load, the second which is inescapable
is time.

Once you get a land mass, then you can progress to topological aesthetics, to the look and feel, a lot of that
comes from learning and adjusting the xml values. There is fog intensity and color, storm particles and timing,
Tree and decorative meaning block layout probability. Then you would have entity population.

Biome layout Is paint preference, you can paint it any way you choose, following altitude in which ever order
you like meaning Snow forest burnt desert waste from top to bottom, split it into quadrants with all five blended,
or autoassign, it is only limited by you and the time you are willing to invest in doing it. Since I love it, I just reduce
the screen and watch a movie simultaneously while setting it up. But for a one button end all be all, it probably will
not happen, and it became clear with the last explanation, I received from @faatal in the diary.

Pois, once you learn the engine rules, regarding grayscale population, then painting the base terrain at specific
shades will either render large cluster groups, small cluster groups, individuals, or make it open wilderness separation.
Roads and road smoothing, are gradients, they can be laid on top, be rough or smooth, or cut swathes through terrain.

Entities, = timing configs, per area.

Seemles biomes, Is painting and experimenting, Just decide your blending distance, and fractalize the the image, Paint
the two merging biome colors, overlay and combine the layers, and repeat at each of the borders, the game will do the
rest, by populating mixing and matching the topsoil decor. It will also spawn mixed entitiy groups.
Then pick the spectrum you favor, and set it for all but the Wasteland to differentiate it.

Basically the way the game engine works is, what you put in is what you are going to get out, the more time the more
customized detail. On my 10k x 10k, I have all of the above, lakes that span the map, their diameter, up to 2 kilometers,
Traders in non standard biome config, land bridges, and it is split into two terrain areas diagonally, with varying poi
cluster sizes, overlooks to take in scenery, rough trails, and smooth roads. And entity spawn to support it. I have yet to
clear half of it yet, and I play sweep and clear. I always find an area along the way to a trader or another poi, that catches
my interest and I bivouac there, and spend some time, collecting a domesticating the area before I move on.

Grass If you want taller, just scale it. And add a light reduction to trees, cvar if it is daytime, to simulate hiding in the shade.
 
Maybe nothing. Could be different biomes with unique features are uninteresting to you. In my opinion, it is what makes Minecraft's infinitely generated world work so well. Yes, you would still have repetition but you would have to travel farther in order to experience that repetition. With 10 biomes or more on our current largest map size the biomes would have to be much smaller area-wise. But with 10 or more biomes at the current biome size for the largest current map size we would need a much larger map aka infinitely generated in order to fit them all in. Plus you could play an entire game and not ever see 1-2 of the biomes because of the direction you chose to travel but then in a following playthrough you might find those biomes.

Swamp (one block deep water everywhere with sleepers)
Plains
Flooded City (First 1-2 stories of buildings under water)
Cavernous (Cave networks abound here)
Maple Forest (split the current forest into this and the following)
Pine Forest
Burnt Forest
Desert
Mesa (more mountainous and colorful with deep canyons and tall mesas)
Wasteland
Snow

Yes, those would repeat on an infinite map for people traveling 20km but they would have to travel 20km to find them. And maybe the flooded city and cavernous biomes are rare so they have to be found and repeat much less often if at all.
You’re definitely painting a rosy picture, but it’s just too tempting. If TFP is willing to implement the ecosystems you’ve proposed, it will earn even higher praise. To be honest, I also think there aren’t enough ecosystems right now. I’d love to see the ecosystems you’ve proposed appear in the game and spread throughout the infinite world.
Post automatically merged:

You were presenting it as a blocking issue to implementing infinite worlds; this has very little to do with my interests, or yours. As a thought experiment, could we produce an infinite world of just forest biome? Obviously yes. Variance would obviously come from something else; but it could still make for great feeling worlds, especially if the world gen properly supported it: see a river, and you can follow it wherever it leads, be it mountains upstream, or a lake downstream.
Yes. That’s exactly how it feels—I can explore along the river and find a spot nestled between the mountains and the water to make my post-apocalyptic home. It feels amazing.
Post automatically merged:

I believe the two biggest barriers to getting infinite worlds are, first, that TFP has no plans to create additional biomes. This game has five biomes. That's it. Five biomes will never be enough variety to make an infinite world work well. Before pushing for infinite worlds, you have to first change TFP's mind about limiting the world to five biomes and good luck with that.

The second obstacle is consoles not being able to run a stable infinite world ever. That's the reality and that is where this dream dies. Sorry for the reality check.

But....if you can convince TFP to double the number of biomes and develop a major exclusive feature for PC that consoles can't have after TFP suffered through years of reading complaints from customers of the Telltale version that their version was different from PC, then maybe you've got a shot.
As long as someone is willing to propose an excellent plan, I don’t think TFP would turn down such an appealing change. I feel they lack a truly viable plan, as I haven’t seen any truly creative additions in the last few versions. So why not start with the ecosystem and map expansions? Otherwise, it seems to me that the game’s development has stalled at this point.
 
Yes, I have played A15 and the prior 8, So I got to experience the changes as they happened.
Archived almost each of the versions 82 vanilla so far, and 30 modded from then until now and play
Round robin going through them to get Ideas for personal changes.

As @Riamus posted Teragon can make the rivers and lakes also, I use it with a map I created to fine tune
the details of the terrain, once I have my layout as I like.

The reason I referred to Nitrogen is because, of what you posted as your desire, and the pictures you
presented. The way for you to get closer to what you want, is through personal customization. Starting
at the terrain, you would need to use an image editor to adjust the grayscale, that will give the elevation
differences. Then for the large waterways and bodies of water, you would have to drop the grayscale
below a specific height, and the game will auto populate, it with water. They never removed the ability
people just stopped using it as much. For mountains, to get erosion effects there are two main ways that
I have seen so far. Get a geo height map, Or I then would defer to Teragon. But the more custom and away
form the default, the more caveates you must be willing to accept. Meaning, the more tris details on the
top landform, the more you have to adjust your own setting to balance load, the second which is inescapable
is time.

Once you get a land mass, then you can progress to topological aesthetics, to the look and feel, a lot of that
comes from learning and adjusting the xml values. There is fog intensity and color, storm particles and timing,
Tree and decorative meaning block layout probability. Then you would have entity population.

Biome layout Is paint preference, you can paint it any way you choose, following altitude in which ever order
you like meaning Snow forest burnt desert waste from top to bottom, split it into quadrants with all five blended,
or autoassign, it is only limited by you and the time you are willing to invest in doing it. Since I love it, I just reduce
the screen and watch a movie simultaneously while setting it up. But for a one button end all be all, it probably will
not happen, and it became clear with the last explanation, I received from @faatal in the diary.

Pois, once you learn the engine rules, regarding grayscale population, then painting the base terrain at specific
shades will either render large cluster groups, small cluster groups, individuals, or make it open wilderness separation.
Roads and road smoothing, are gradients, they can be laid on top, be rough or smooth, or cut swathes through terrain.

Entities, = timing configs, per area.

Seemles biomes, Is painting and experimenting, Just decide your blending distance, and fractalize the the image, Paint
the two merging biome colors, overlay and combine the layers, and repeat at each of the borders, the game will do the
rest, by populating mixing and matching the topsoil decor. It will also spawn mixed entitiy groups.
Then pick the spectrum you favor, and set it for all but the Wasteland to differentiate it.

Basically the way the game engine works is, what you put in is what you are going to get out, the more time the more
customized detail. On my 10k x 10k, I have all of the above, lakes that span the map, their diameter, up to 2 kilometers,
Traders in non standard biome config, land bridges, and it is split into two terrain areas diagonally, with varying poi
cluster sizes, overlooks to take in scenery, rough trails, and smooth roads. And entity spawn to support it. I have yet to
clear half of it yet, and I play sweep and clear. I always find an area along the way to a trader or another poi, that catches
my interest and I bivouac there, and spend some time, collecting a domesticating the area before I move on.

Grass If you want taller, just scale it. And add a light reduction to trees, cvar if it is daytime, to simulate hiding in the shade.
Thank you to all the community members who suggested the Teragon solution; it has indeed partially resolved my current issue. However, it would be even better if TFP could be modified.
 
Back
Top