PC Alpha 21 Discussion Overflow

Guppycur said:
Absolutely.  But you may want to look at the post I was responding to.  
Click to expand...
Nevermind. I thought about it, and now I somehow doubt that it is even necessary to keep the game easy/accessible for players that are absolutely new to the game.

Is has been in early access for so long now, that one could think everybody who wants to play the game already has got it,

so when it is finally going gold, every newbie already has at least 1000hours of experience. 😀

 
Catdaddy said:
Agree. So is stacking them.

So keep jars in game, but never stackable, full or empty.

This way they still exist but are extremely inefficient to abuse.

You could still take a backpack full of single jars to the river and fill them one at a time for a few days of water, if you want. You enjoy that. I'll be over there setting up my fancy new dew collector farm.

Win/win? 
Click to expand...
 You do realize this will and should also make any other jar non stackable right, so all drinks, even those from your dew collector that now need to also be supplied with clean jars.

 
Haidrgna said:
 You do realize this will and should also make any other jar non stackable right, so all drinks, even those from your dew collector that now need to also be supplied with clean jars.
Click to expand...
Aren't stacksizes determined individually for every item, independent from one may or may not be an ingredient for another?

And the "should be" part: well let's not start the "why can I carry 6000m³ of concrete but only one piece of XY" thingy.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yeh you can make empty's be the only ones non stackable, since it's its own item.

...but also, remember there's going to be an influx of new users from the casual console types.  Probably more than PC.

Jost Amman said:
All I see here are speculations... I have a proposal for The Fun Pimps: please give a courtesy copy of the current A21 revision to both @Guppycur and @KhaineGB and let them give you feedback about how they feel the water change is by actually testing it.

At least after that, if they trash the changes, they'll do it knowledgeably.  :kev:
Click to expand...
I'd have thought that by now you'd have realized that the dev diary *is for* speculation.  Hell, Roland makes a game out of it.

I suppose by your standards, this should be a read-only thread, or maybe only allow suck up posts?

 
meilodasreh said:
Aren't stacksizes determined individually for every item, independent from one may or may not be an ingredient for another?

And the "should be" part: well let's not start the "why can I carry 6000m³ of concrete but only one piece of XY" thingy.
Click to expand...
Yes stacksizes are determined per item, but makes little sense to apply the change to one if all other similar items would not have that change done to them, that was my point. So if we would go with making each 'jar' or canteen or whatever we use to carry liquid in item would stack to one, it would be odd if once they are filled they suddenly stack to 10 again.

The concrete argument is your fabrication, not mine.

 
Haidrgna said:
Yes stacksizes are determined per item, but makes little sense to apply the change to one if all other similar items would not have that change done to them, that was my point.
Click to expand...
There already are lots of those things you call "would be weird".

You can carry 125 murky water in one stack, but all the "processed" stuff like coffee, boiled water, teas and so on only stack to 10.

I always thought that doesn't make sense, but only for reasons of balancing.

Concrete is just the extreme example in that context.

 
Guppycur said:
...but also, remember there's going to be an influx of new users from the casual console types.  Probably more than PC.
Click to expand...
This is not explanation - you have hard and complexed games on consoles. Just they want to get the most wide player base. 

That's why i love NMRIH - some "new" players wanted to removed zombie kids but  devs decided not because the oldest ( people conneted with this game since begining ) fans accepted that game is not for everyone - NMRINH 2 is good example why it's better to focus on "hardenst" fans not on getting more and more of them

 
Guppycur said:
It's simpler.  Now we have magic blocks that turn into water.  That's less complicated than having to trudge out to get water, even if it's by one step.

Before:

Step 1) fill water bottle.

Step 2) boil water bottle.

A21:

Step 1) make magic block.

...it's not a lot of additional complication, but it is more.
Click to expand...


The process to get a renewable water source is what I was referring to. You are comparing getting a jar of boiled water in A20 to getting a jar of boiled water in A21 which is not what I was talking about. Plus the recipe to make the collector is quite a bit more work than filling a water bottle and boiling it. So I will say again that for establishing a renewable drinking water source:

Before:

Step 1) Acquire 10+ bottles

A21:

Step 1) Unlock the Dew Collector Recipe

Step 2) Acquire the ingredients for 10+ Collectors

Its not a lot of additional complication but it is more and takes a lot longer to accomplish.

The alternate ideas you had while pooping and also the one that limits you to a stack of 1 bottle are interesting as well. Try simulating them and see if they play out as fun. 

I get it that the removal of bottles is going to cause havok for you and Khaine as modders. Whatever recipes and processes you guys put in place that requires empty bottles to be in the game are going to be kaput and you guys will have to go back and overhaul it. Maybe you can just replace empty bottles with broken glass and the forging of the broken glass into bottles part is just abstracted or mod the pot to be a filled pot which could then take the place of bottles of murky water. Who knows, maybe Allan will look at some of these ideas and incorporate some of it.

 
Guppycur said:
I'd have thought that by now you'd have realized that the dev diary *is for* speculation.  Hell, Roland makes a game out of it.

I suppose by your standards, this should be a read-only thread, or maybe only allow suck up posts?
Click to expand...
Well, yes and no.

You know, by my standards, you speculate when you don't know much about something. But with the new water system, for the first time, we have a very detailed explanation of both features and gameplay "feel", from the people who are testing it. Now, I know you're not someone who trusts random people like the devs, but personally if they straight out give you a detailed report of what the new water system will be, I at least give them the benefit of the doubt and believe what they say.

So, basically, you and several other people (specifically the more mod-talented ones) tend to overthink the matter and/or start going in overdrive mode with your own modded solution to the game issue the devs have been trying to assess. It really looks just like a spitting contest this way.

To each his own I guess.

 
Jost Amman said:
All I see here are speculations... I have a proposal for The Fun Pimps: please give a courtesy copy of the current A21 revision to both @Guppycur and @KhaineGB and let them give you feedback about how they feel the water change is by actually testing it.

At least after that, if they trash the changes, they'll do it knowledgeably.  :kev:
Click to expand...
Damn! If this works, then I will immediately start criticizing the new dew collector, removing cans and offering other ideas! Where is my preliminary A21??? 😅

 
Tete1805 said:
I'm not sure if this has been asked already, but could the drone get out of the way when in 'combat' mode?

At least, when I aim at something with a rifle or a crossbow and such?

Maybe it could get behind you or just on the side.
Click to expand...
I must have skimmed over this post (*), and I agree that the drone can be annoying at times. And it is even more so when multiple players have their drones hovering around after a loot run while we all try to acces storage and there's a drone blocking. The drone can be instructed to "stay put", but one has to lead it to a "parking" spot, interact with it to tell it to quit following, then interact with it again to give the "follow me now" command. Or just place it in your backpack and be done with it until you're in a situation where it may be helpful and hopefully not get in the way of the firing line. Either way, those extra steps are both inconvenient and during combat can get one killed. Tip: Don't try and plant rows of seeds in your garden with it doddering over you. Makes me want to hit it, and if I could maybe that's something we might wish for: to be able to fist punch the darn thing to force it to get behind you. But its healing benefit during combat is awesome. Extra storage is a bonus too. A nice addition to the game, but not flawless. 

(*) Going back through these posts to try and understand the ramifications of the upcoming dew collector station in A21. Its still murky to me. So re-reading and trying to wring out what's to come.  Lots of jarring speculation, sometimes snowballing into argument that only muddies the waters for me. Seasoned players and those still wet behind the ears are having a regatta.  I'm still quite honestly confused. I could do with a drink.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top