Major collapse

I built a base on the middle of a bridge, and just outside my land claim bounds, the entire bridge collapsed for no reason. I lost at least 50 planters, 2 dew collectors, and various storage boxes, full of supplies. I had a stroke four months ago, and my screen time is limited. All that gathering and foraging and the game broke enough to make me not want to play anymore. What am I supposed to do? Xbox..
 
I built a base on the middle of a bridge, and just outside my land claim bounds, the entire bridge collapsed for no reason. I lost at least 50 planters, 2 dew collectors, and various storage boxes, full of supplies. I had a stroke four months ago, and my screen time is limited. All that gathering and foraging and the game broke enough to make me not want to play anymore. What am I supposed to do? Xbox..
You need to be careful with stability, especially with farms. As plants (or trees) grow, they can cause a collapse if they are on a location that has low stability already. Think of it as them getting heavier as they get bigger. It is a good idea to place some kind of support under your farm (just around the middle if it's small, or perhaps multiple supports if it's really large). It is possible it was caused by something else, but since you mentioned the farm plots, I have a feeling that was the reason.

Unfortunately, no matter the reason, there isn't really any way to fix it other than to just use the creative menu to replace the stuff you lost. Other than that, you'd have to just craft and find whatever you lost.
 
I don't think it was a weight issue. Why would it split off at the land claim, precisely?
It may just be coincidence. It'll break at a point where stability is changing, which is related to how close things are to the closest support. That could end up being at a land claim boundary. If you show some screenshots of the collapsed area, including any supports, it might help to verify if that's the likely cause.

The other possibility is if you are playing on a server or P2P, network lag could cause a collapse if only part of the area gets loaded at a time because of the lag, but that's not very common.
 
Assuming you are playing solo, use creative mode to get back what you lost. nothing wrong with that. sometimes i give myself a stack of lockpicks because they are stupid expensive to make(and i hate the lock pick mechanic lol).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lax
Since Basebuilding has become one of the major conversational aspects
of the game.

Maybe request that a button to show stability within your LBD area
only, without using DM may be helpful.

Many people are experimenting with building their ideal for the perfect
base. This might help with learning what can and can't work.

As an alternative to a simple button, a new perk, can be put where Lucky
Looter is. OR it could be added to the top tier of building tools. There
are plenty of options, on how to make it a part of the game.

It would also be useful to Console players, and people that either don't
know about DM CM use, or don't like to use it.

If in solo, it could be any poi.
 
Last edited:
Oh my! Bridges kind of run the ragged edge of structural integrity on their own. You would want to add pillars to help it.

That's one of those things we reliably construct in reality with lots of capacity, but aren't well represented by the game's physics. The POI builders that get away with really wild stuff, like MPLogue, add a custom "air" block that can support weight. You won't have that option in-game without intentionally modding it in.
 
You won't have that option in-game without intentionally modding it in.
Weeelllll.....
I don't know what exact block GNS is using, but I think it's a dynamic pair of railings. Like catwalks/stairs with the railing that disappears from the middle when you place two next to each other - but just the railings. And when that middle railing of "just the railings" disappears, what's left? And I think it can even be "advanced rotate"ed... ;)
 
Weeelllll.....
I don't know what exact block GNS is using, but I think it's a dynamic pair of railings. Like catwalks/stairs with the railing that disappears from the middle when you place two next to each other - but just the railings. And when that middle railing of "just the railings" disappears, what's left? And I think it can even be "advanced rotate"ed... ;)

It's been a while since I looked, but when I was looking at custom blocks he had an air block providing support. He could have had other blocks too. I don't remember any dynamic appearances, which would take code I assume, but custom blocks like that air block can be all XML.
 
I don't remember any dynamic appearances,
Pfft, was hoping you'd remember... so I had to check myself :)
1772113272961.pngScreenshot from 2026-02-26 15-39-42.png

Image is a bit bad, but
From a single block, to two, to three, to four in the vertical,
and lastly a sample of a cube placed on top.
Each "floating" railing is the top of a pillar of railings, perfectly structurally sound, with player-craftable blocks.

And the cube makes the railing dynamically disappear; terrain on the bottom doesn't, but if you start on a cube, it will vanish too.
 
Pfft, was hoping you'd remember... so I had to check myself :)
View attachment 38563View attachment 38564

Image is a bit bad, but
From a single block, to two, to three, to four in the vertical,
and lastly a sample of a cube placed on top.
Each "floating" railing is the top of a pillar of railings, perfectly structurally sound, with player-craftable blocks.

I'm not sure what I'm supposed to look at. I would say I don't normally look to railings for structural integrity since they're normally used horizontally. For support, I'm concerned about vertical support. Horizontal support falls off for certain, and vertical support is needed to extend horizontal support.

Or maybe I just don't understand what folks are talking about.
 
I'm not sure what I'm supposed to look at. I would say I don't normally look to railings for structural integrity since they're normally used horizontally. For support, I'm concerned about vertical support. Horizontal support falls off for certain, and vertical support is needed to extend horizontal support.

Or maybe I just don't understand what folks are talking about.
Basically, the block makes it so you can have invisible (but still tangible) vertical supports just by rotating it on its side. Zombies can still attack them, so it's not really cheating, it's just useful for aesthetic purposes.
 
I'm not sure what I'm supposed to look at.
You're looking at pillars of essentially air blocks, made from blocks accessible to the vanilla player. The dynamically adjusting railing blocks happily adjust themselves out of existence when capped by blocks at the railing sides. This can be turned into an air pillar.
 
I'm not sure what I'm supposed to look at. I would say I don't normally look to railings for structural integrity since they're normally used horizontally. For support, I'm concerned about vertical support. Horizontal support falls off for certain, and vertical support is needed to extend horizontal support.

Or maybe I just don't understand what folks are talking about.
It's a hack, basically. When placed on their side, on top of each other, they disappear. People cheese them to make floating bases. It's funny how people complain about stuff like armor bonuses being "magical" and yet people build floating bases. At least with the armor, you can come up with explanations for why a bonus is on them, even if it's farfetched. But a floating base? Heh.

The streamers are all using this method, I believe. But POI builders are more likely to use air blocks, imo.
 
It's funny how people complain about stuff like armor bonuses being "magical" and yet people build floating bases.
Do you expect us who dislike magical armor just to stop using using armor altogether; or can we complain about bad design and still utilize it while it exists?
 
Do you expect us who dislike magical armor just to stop using using armor altogether; or can we complain about bad design and still utilize it while it exists?
Some have asked for plain armor option so they could avoid the bonuses. You of course won't just not use any armor. But floating bases are entirely optional.
 
You're looking at pillars of essentially air blocks, made from blocks accessible to the vanilla player. The dynamically adjusting railing blocks happily adjust themselves out of existence when capped by blocks at the railing sides. This can be turned into an air pillar.
However, zombies easily break such an air column.
I'm not sure what I'm supposed to look at. I would say I don't normally look to railings for structural integrity since they're normally used horizontally. For support, I'm concerned about vertical support. Horizontal support falls off for certain, and vertical support is needed to extend horizontal support.
If a block has vertical support, it is always unlimited. Only horizontal support has limitations.
 
Back
Top