PC Is Melee Dead? I think so...

Since the chance to blow the head off the zombie is only 15% I still prefer the rad remover :)
That's why you take Flurry of Blows as well. It might be bugged, but I get heads exploding with melee pretty much all the time. (with a Club, *not* a Sledge)

 
I love playing melee but I also agree with you. It would be awesome if perks gave us some more acrobatic or deft moves such as kicking, dodges, parties, etc. even a move to sidestep a zombie’s swipe if timed right and then be able to bash them on the side of the head would be awesome.
There is some fun to darting in and out and consistently getting the timing perfect on the sledgehammer is quite satisfying but there definitely are some great examples of melee fighting TFP could take as inspiration for perks if what we have now could be called basic Day 1 fighting moves. In addition, those who don’t want the game to feel too arcady with special fight combos wouldn’t have to see them or learn them if they were locked behind perks.
Finishing moves! :fat:

 
You can put as many points into melee as you want but without a rad remover in your club or hammer it's hard to kill a radioactive zombie that will regenerate pretty quickly after a hit.
In addition, you rarely have to deal with only one radioactive zombie at the same time. Most of the time I have 2-5 on my heels and a few ferals on top of that. This is something different than when you have to do it with a single radioactive zombie.

In the video you can see that the player with two radioactive zombies already has some problems and has to get the shotgun out.
As promised, I made a video using only the bow and the club. As you can see, I'm really not good at melee, but the skills do the job.

Look at the second video.

https://7daystodie.com/forums/showthread.php?107645-Enjoying-Alpha-17-in-videos&p=937514&viewfull=1#post937514

 
Is melee dead?

I dunno, I'll tell you after I clear this POI with my steel armor and flaming sledgehammer. I'm too busy smashing in skulls and power swinging stunned zombies, and sweeping back multiple Zs AoE style to really give the "melee is dead" much credence.

 
Is melee dead?
I dunno, I'll tell you after I clear this POI with my steel armor and flaming sledgehammer. I'm too busy smashing in skulls and power swinging stunned zombies, and sweeping back multiple Zs AoE style to really give the "melee is dead" much credence.

I like getting 130 in stamina too. That little extra allows more power swings to start getting back 50 stamina on kills. Nothing I like too much in the agility area so more points would be a waste.

 
Posts like this is what kept me away from a17 for so long. I was truly convinced the developers made all these awful game breaking changes, when in fact, turns out, most of the changes make a lot of sense. A17 is like a new game in a lot of ways, but a far superior game in my honest opinion. Yeah there's a lot of bugs and such, obviously, but the new mod system is great. The skill system, which I was convinced was terrible (largely in part due to similar styled posts), turns out to be pretty damn decent. It actually makes you think about what you're going to invest in, a purpose to earning xp. I think most people play for an hour, female dog about the game actually having some difficulty now, and then never bother to understand the changes the developers made. (Myself included). Once you advance a few levels, melee becomes much more efficient. In fact, I barely ever used melee before A17, but now that I understand the mod system and such, I've begun to use it almost exclusively.

It's a zombie apocalypse for christ sake.. You shouldn't be able to take on a horde of zombies with a club and then fly off in your gyrocopter the first time, every time.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Aside from the really annoying music, that was awesome. I really want to try that, especially since the swing speed of punching is pretty good.
Anyway, melee ain't dead. I'm still crushing it with my flaming sledge (though I have started to carry a gun for those rad spiders and rad bikers).
A few saves ago I would literally go out and provoke screamers, drink beer or moonshine and punch radiated zombies for fun with my level over 100. Melee is definitely not dead.

 
As promised, I made a video using only the bow and the club. As you can see, I'm really not good at melee, but the skills do the job.
Look at the second video.

https://7daystodie.com/forums/showthread.php?107645-Enjoying-Alpha-17-in-videos&p=937514&viewfull=1#post937514
Using perks to permanently stunlock all enemies = Melee works?

This is why i am disappointed in the people argueing for melee being good.

Well im sorry but i have to disagree. Thats a pretty terrible system and going around perma-stunning anything would be seen to many in all kinds of games as either exploitive or downright terrible game design. 7D2D is not a special snowflake that gets a free pass when it comes to making BALANCE.

Infinite stunlock is not balance.

 
SnakeWildlife, I went back through your posts in this thread, and I can't find a constructive word from you about what you think melee should be. You mostly complained about stamina making it impossible. When people replied how they negated the stamina problem, you said that their argument was invalid. (The funny part here is that you said melee is not a valid "build," which would seem to negate your negation since what they did was build their character in such a way as to avoid the stamina problem of melee. Even funnier, you talked about how you could build an early range character to be effective, emphasis on the "build" part.)

So then, according to you, range is far superior because you don't have to worry about that stuff because you can run away and kite them and...wait for it...STUN them with your shots. Interesting.

While we're here, hitting your opponent so fast and hard that they have no time/opportunity to hit you back is an excellent boxing tactic. The problem is that you open yourself up to a tough beating in return if it doesn't work. You'll notice that Hek Harris did take some licks in that video.

So, maybe be better at arguing?

 
I melee about 98% of non-bloodmoon play. I don't like the "all-or-nothing" aspect of the sledge, so it's all club. Once you get the needed perks all in place (yeah, there's a lot if you want to battle irradiateds), and a full set of Steel with Heavy armor maxed out, you can actually tank a bit when needed. Avoid/kite/shoot the damn biker zombies if they double-team you.

-Morloc

 
@Snake, you sure love saying everything people are saying that makes melee works are stupid and wrong, but not saying anything that you think balances it. Melee is the only reason I survive versus rad-armies on survivalists solo. Guns, sure, but that's going to eat more ammo than I have RL time to farm for. Since you negated everything so far, I guess your "balancing" would be to make melee a 1-hit kill AOE that requires a general aiming? Lol

 
I guess your "balancing" would be to make melee a 1-hit kill AOE that requires a general aiming? Lol
Melee would be perfect if we could craft the Nidavellir forge upgrade and then make Mjِlnir. Anything less than that is basic.

 
Melee would be perfect if we could craft the Nidavellir forge upgrade and then make Mjِlnir. Anything less than that is basic.
Nah, imagine using some of the weapons portrayed in Bloodborneo or the Souls series... THERE were some really fun melee weapons...

 
I had the same problem as the op and quit playing! After reading this thread, I'm Back!!!

Gonna deck myself out a melee character. Super excited!

How about some suggestions on the best perks / order?

 
Strenght of course, for the melee damages. Then Skull Crusher for the bonus when hitting the head. Sex T. and cardio (agility) for the stamina. If you choose the club : flurry of blows. Sledge hammer ? Heavy Metal. Machette ? Deep Cuts. Stay down ! can wait but is usefull too.

In parallel but less urgent, pain tolerance & light or heavy armor.

And imods for your favorite weapon, they are unavoidable.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Strenght of course, for the melee damages. Then Skull Crusher for the bonus when hitting the head. Sex T. and cardio (agility) for the stamina. If you choose the club : flurry of blows. Sledge hammer ? Heavy Metal. Machette ? Deep Cuts. Stay down ! can wait but is usefull too.In parallel but less urgent, pain tolerance & light or heavy armor.

And imods for your favorite weapon, they are unavoidable.
You, sir, are a gentleman and a scholar!

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top