Am I just underestimating the value of the discussion?
Umm, let's not turn this into another Jar Tread, sorry for joking about it, but I blame Roland for starting it again!

Underestimating? Depends entirely on how you view it, there's half a dozen steps to "the water changes" that I dislike, and no upsides. There are plenty of people who like some or most of it. There's just SO MUCH intertwined stuff involved that it will never be "resolved".
And some of us are just wasting time here anyway, so the amount of discussion doesn't correlate with the importance of a topic.
EDIT: And ok, might as well answer the OP as well:
I usually just buy it now. Unless I'm running a miner build, the shale is rather slow now (which feels ok), and you can get a lot of discounts stacking the "common" discounts (sugar butts, awesome sauce, cigar, barter hat, magnum, cheesecake make for a 60% discount).