Aldranon
New member
The reason why inaccurate and slow firing muskets replaced bows and x-bows was: the increased damage and better armor penetration of the musket won battles.You'd be surprised what an arrow wil go through, what it lacks in speed it makes up for in mass and inertia. An arrow will go through a modern suit of kevlar armour better than a bullet although you're correct that there's far less hydrostatic damage of the surrounding tissue.
You can get more damage by using a proper war arrowhead like a bodkin, although they're technically illegal in the UK you can get them for the price of a couple of beers from your local medieval blacksmithing re-enactor.
[trigger warning : arrow through a skull]
https://i2.wp.com/memolition.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/1198.jpg?fit=758%2C800
Now 1 vs 1, I'd take a x-bow because if we both miss, I'd run over and stab him with a bolt while he's reloading!
