Not only that, but I tested my melee horde base again
Spears are definitely not great, but melee horde base would be kind of doable so long as you max out Junk Sledges. I've been testing Junk Sledge more and you can do something like I did for the front door of my base.
I built a Day 49 horde base to test out the theory above taken to the extreme, and it worked okay. Basically just made a 1 block wide hallway with 3 block thick concrete walls with blocks openings in the roof so I could throw explosives down on clusters, and put a bunch of junk sleges outside the front while I blocked the hallway entrance with a top and bottom hatch spaced so there is a window to fire through. I made it like 6 blocks tall so they couldn't pyramid on top of it, then at the end of the hallway I had a ladder up to a 10 or so block tall tower I stood on top of it as needed.
Here are the post day 49 horde results
All turrets shown are mine, my duo didn't place a single one to help. In fact, I don't think he did anything to help besides scream about birds a lot =_=
I placed so many because they break during the horde so you need backups, but only 2 were active at a time. It worked okay, they broke two levels of vault hatch barricades and probably 10-20 total concrete blocks, but 99% of that was stupid exploding zombies and their stupid c4 being triggered by everything under the sun. Those would be enemy #1 for any melee horde base, because they are enemy #1 for every base no matter what. You have to build your entire base design around them which is why so many people hate them
Of course, I didn't use melee myself because I'm not suicidal, so I just stood there and threw around 70 pipe bombs and 10 molotovs, because explosives are OP AF.
Pop Atom Junkie, Pop learning elixir, spend pocket change resources on a stack of 100 pipe bombs, never engage in melee and don't waste all your bullets = Profit
You could do the above, use a skull crusher, painkiller, moonshine, health bar etc, and stand in the door and swing your melee weapon, and it would do okayish depending on your difficulty. I play on the second hardest difficulty with 24 or 32 zombies alive, so melee would be pretty hard "Lolno" territory though, even with a Sledge which at least has AoE
Sledgehammer needs some love. All melee weapons and guns have their books with buffs, only sledge doesnt have any.
As a main sledge player I feel offended :rain: Give us more affection, don’t hate us
Yeah, it would be nice to see each weapon type get it's own focused line of magazines, but to be fair, the Sledgehammer has been the inarguable best melee weapon in the game for like 4+ alpha at least lol. I generally use the Axe over it, and some might want a club over it for stamina, but if you have sex rex and want the weapon that lets you dive face first into a horde with some small chance of surviving, the Sledge is your best option by far.
I still really think we need a perk line that grants health on kill with melee, that alone would make melee builds actually sort of feasible late game.