@madmole Hm... regarding the agility and melee weapons. I think why it feels so weak is primarily due the extreme differences in weapon damage, stamina cost, and durability. Comparing a hunting knife of quality 5 vs a machete of same quality.Hunting knife:
Damage (basic attack): 8
Power attack damge: 28
Stamina cost: 5
Attacks/ Minute: 120
VS
Machete same quality of 5
Damage basic attack: 26
Power attack damage: 45
Stamina cost: 12
Attacks/ Minute: 55
It's no wonder why the rank 1 and rank 2 melee for agility feels lacklustre. Essentially, if you want full potential you pretty much need a machete or just rely on the bleeding effect. Though, on the other hand once Alpha 18.2 comes out we shall see if it still needs another pass, as the knives are being buffed with a speed debuff as well.
As for the spears? Why not also allow them to penetrate zombies, considering that perception really is all about that trait.