PC Is there a plan to return to survival horror?

S

Simplycasualgaming

New member
As the game stands, it has left the survival horror genere and is just an arcade shooter/Tower Defense game. Death isnt a penalty. Scavaging is a joke with perks/books and double looting PoIs. At no point after day one do I have to worry about survivng and I dont even need to build a base for forever.

 
You can play Hardcore Survivalist mod.
This mod keeps the vanilla feel, but nerfs everything to bring survival back into the game.
Less quality in loot.
Less harvest from blocks, including salvaging and butchering.
Traders are also heavily nerfed too, so no more online shopping getting everything you want!
You start infected and have to keep the infection under control, until you can find the cure, which can be found in the one custom T5 POI that is added for an end game challenge.

https://github.com/Frantic-Dan/Hardcore-Survivalist-Just-Die-Already

 
FranticDan said:
You can play Hardcore Survivalist mod.
This mod keeps the vanilla feel, but nerfs everything to bring survival back into the game.
Less quality in loot.
Less harvest from blocks, including salvaging and butchering.
Traders are also heavily nerfed too, so no more online shopping getting everything you want!
You start infected and have to keep the infection under control, until you can find the cure, which can be found in the one custom T5 POI that is added for an end game challenge.

https://github.com/Frantic-Dan/Hardcore-Survivalist-Just-Die-Already
Click to expand...
Cool. I will look into it, just kinda feels bad that I need a mod to make a survival horror game actually be survival horror.

 
The unfortunate thing for people who want hardcore survival aspects in the game is that such players are a very niche group.  If the game caters specifically to them, it will sell far fewer copies than if it caters to a wider group that isn't looking for a grind.  That isn't to say they can't make things more difficult, which they are trying to do with water scarcity, but I wouldn't expect too much change at this point when they are pushing for gold.

Personally, if I had to work too hard to find things, I probably wouldn't play the game.  Challenge is fine but having to try forever to find enough of XYZ isn't my idea of fun.  It's like games that make ammo so scarce that you basically can't use guns except in limited situations... I usually quit playing those game after a couple of hours or never play them.  Sure, it's realistic.  But fun?  No.  That's just my own preferences and others have different preferences.

As mentioned, you can use mods to get at least close to what you are looking for.  And you don't have to double loot a POI.  I know you can but it isn't a requirement.  It is extremely rare that I will do that regardless of the loot because it just feels too gamey.

 
play dead is dead. Plenty of penalty there. Thats the only way I like to play. Makes every decision or encounter matter. water is going to be much harder to come by A21, so survival will certainly get harder.

There are so many settings available to increase difficulty. Too much loot, lower it. Too easy to kill zeds, increase difficulty. Dont need a base for a long time. Make horde night every night. 

The settings are there, and TFP has done a great job of giving us the flexibility built into the framework to achieve the desired game configuration.

 
rateds2k said:
Why does it feel bad? They set up this game to be very mod friendly so you can have almost any game play you want.  Wish all games were like this.  You get your survival horror feel and someone else gets another type of game play.
Click to expand...
Oh no, im glad the game is mod friendly. I just don't like that I need to mod the game to actually make it fit into its genre.

 
Riamus said:
The unfortunate thing for people who want hardcore survival aspects in the game is that such players are a very niche group.  If the game caters specifically to them, it will sell far fewer copies than if it caters to a wider group that isn't looking for a grind.  That isn't to say they can't make things more difficult, which they are trying to do with water scarcity, but I wouldn't expect too much change at this point when they are pushing for gold.

Personally, if I had to work too hard to find things, I probably wouldn't play the game.  Challenge is fine but having to try forever to find enough of XYZ isn't my idea of fun.  It's like games that make ammo so scarce that you basically can't use guns except in limited situations... I usually quit playing those game after a couple of hours or never play them.  Sure, it's realistic.  But fun?  No.  That's just my own preferences and others have different preferences.

As mentioned, you can use mods to get at least close to what you are looking for.  And you don't have to double loot a POI.  I know you can but it isn't a requirement.  It is extremely rare that I will do that regardless of the loot because it just feels too gamey.
Click to expand...
They don't have to make it super grindy, but eating glass shouldn't be a viable healing methoed.

 
I know some people have trouble with this concept, but if you don't have fun double looting, eating glass, etc.... just don't do it.

I just logged off a bit ago from a new game that will be my last a20 game.

I had intended to find a remnant poi and restore/rebuild it for a base. However, just north of the starting forest trader was a beautiful lake with snowy mountain peaks across on the other side of the lake.  With such a beautiful spot, i decided i had to build my own base. 

I did one quest. I didn't spam quests, because i was in the mood to explore the town to see what was there, plus loot mailboxes/newspaper stands because i am going to focus archery. I did what i found fun and interesting with absolutely no concern what was optimal.

After exploring for a while, i focused more on resource gathering on the way to my lakeside base location. When i got there, i had enough materials to build a small starter base, get my campfire and forge down, make a cooking pot, and start making bacon and eggs.  

I do what i feel like doing and what makes sense in a "what do i need most now to survive in a zombie apocalypse" frame of mind, not in a "what can i do to min/max the game mechanics" frame of mind.

I don't double loot because i find it boring. I don't eat glass because suicide is never the choice for "what do i need most to survive". I learn the things that help me with my survival goals. If i have no current important goals, i choose to do what feels fun, interesting, or rewarding at that particular moment.

I have played since a15. I still find the vanilla game to be my favorite game. I play several of the overhaul mods and enjoy them too, but i play them for a change of pace, not because i find vanilla lacking.

Some people seem to intentionally do things that make the game no longer fun for them. I just don't do that.

 
Simplycasualgaming said:
As the game stands, it has left the survival horror genere and is just an arcade shooter/Tower Defense game. Death isnt a penalty. Scavaging is a joke with perks/books and double looting PoIs. At no point after day one do I have to worry about survivng and I dont even need to build a base for forever.
Click to expand...


The great thing about this particular problem is that you have the power to change everything about it.

 
katarynna said:
I know some people have trouble with this concept, but if you don't have fun double looting, eating glass, etc.... just don't do it.

I just logged off a bit ago from a new game that will be my last a20 game.

I had intended to find a remnant poi and restore/rebuild it for a base. However, just north of the starting forest trader was a beautiful lake with snowy mountain peaks across on the other side of the lake.  With such a beautiful spot, i decided i had to build my own base. 

I did one quest. I didn't spam quests, because i was in the mood to explore the town to see what was there, plus loot mailboxes/newspaper stands because i am going to focus archery. I did what i found fun and interesting with absolutely no concern what was optimal.

After exploring for a while, i focused more on resource gathering on the way to my lakeside base location. When i got there, i had enough materials to build a small starter base, get my campfire and forge down, make a cooking pot, and start making bacon and eggs.  

I do what i feel like doing and what makes sense in a "what do i need most now to survive in a zombie apocalypse" frame of mind, not in a "what can i do to min/max the game mechanics" frame of mind.

I don't double loot because i find it boring. I don't eat glass because suicide is never the choice for "what do i need most to survive". I learn the things that help me with my survival goals. If i have no current important goals, i choose to do what feels fun, interesting, or rewarding at that particular moment.

I have played since a15. I still find the vanilla game to be my favorite game. I play several of the overhaul mods and enjoy them too, but i play them for a change of pace, not because i find vanilla lacking.

Some people seem to intentionally do things that make the game no longer fun for them. I just don't do that.
Click to expand...
That's a very well-written post.  I also feel that if a player is doing something they don't enjoy, that they should just not do it.  Many people think that because it's the most efficient option that they have no choice but to do it.  That simply isn't true.  If you enjoy playing that way, then go for it.  But if you don't enjoy playing that way, it really isn't difficult to not do it anymore.  Games are meant to have fun and if your playstyle isn't fun for you, then choose a playstyle that is instead.  Who really cares if it isn't the most efficient option?  This isn't something like many WoW guilds doing raids, where being a half second off in your timing will get you ridiculed and have everyone yelling at you.  This is a game where you can play for fun without any need to try and be efficient or min/max if you don't want to.  You can easily play the game without doing that and still do just fine in the game.  Understand that it is acceptable to not be efficient in a game if you find it more fun that way.  That doesn't mean you can't be efficient in some things while not being efficient in others.  If you like being efficient in base building and enjoy that but don't like it for double looting, then be efficient with your base building and don't double loot.  Play in a way that makes you happy.  And let others play the way they like.  If someone in your group likes double looting, then let them.  It doesn't mean you have to do so.  If they want to eat glass, then that's their choice.  You don't have to do it.

The game doesn't have to force you to play a certain way.  You can make choices for yourself.  :)

 
Riamus said:
I did what i found fun and interesting with absolutely no concern what was optimal.
Click to expand...
This is the way.  (Accidentally select-quoted the wrong person though. Sorry!)

 
Last edited:
Simplycasualgaming said:
As the game stands, it has left the survival horror genere and is just an arcade shooter/Tower Defense game. Death isnt a penalty. Scavaging is a joke with perks/books and double looting PoIs. At no point after day one do I have to worry about survivng and I dont even need to build a base for forever.
Click to expand...
You can up the difficulty and you can reduce the amount of loot available in the game without any mods.  You can choose to play dead is dead.  You can choose to add what-ever self imposed rules you want to make the experience you want it to be.  Glock9(iirc) just recently ended a no crafting challenge that was surprisingly fun to watch.  Make the game that you want to play.

Do i think there should be more difficulty options for hardcore gamers? absolutely!  But in early access i don't see the point in adding it now, when there are more important things to focus on.

 
Simplycasualgaming said:
Oh no, im glad the game is mod friendly. I just don't like that I need to mod the game to actually make it fit into its genre.
Click to expand...


Changing the vanilla settings allows you to up the difficulty, reduce the loot, increase the zombies, no mods needed. Can even randomise the frequency of the horde night, or set it to every night? What else would you say is missing from making it a survival horror? Or rather, what have they changed?

 
Fit its genre? SInce 7 Days to Die borrows elements from several genres to define its own hybrid style, I'm pretty sure that whatever it does is going to fit its genre. If you want to emphasize one particular genre like Survival Horror then you'll need to adjust your playstyle and/or change the settings and/or mod the game. It isn't sad. It's fantastic.

Survival Horror typically involves severe limits on ammo and weaponry and relies mostly on mood, setting, creepy sound effects and music, limited visibility, evasion, and puzzle solving. 

To me, pure survival horror would be doing a quest at Higashi Tower at night with a handheld flashlight and no weapons and the settings put to maximum difficulty so that zombie HP is too high for you to be able to actually kill them. They could be set to walk at night or perhaps jog but you would need to constantly run and evade, shut doors behind you, build barricades, get knockdowns with your fists to buy yourself time as you loot and try to accomplish the quest with relentless zombies constantly on your tail. Will you get cornered? Will something jump out unexpectedly from the darkness? That is what adds to the suspense. That would be closest to classic survival horror but I'm glad the game isn't purely defined by that. I can try doing it as a challenge or to get that survival horror feeling but then the next time I can go in with plenty of ammo and do it more like an arcade shooter or I can go in the next time and try to stealth as much as possible.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Riamus said:
The unfortunate thing for people who want hardcore survival aspects in the game is that such players are a very niche group.  If the game caters specifically to them, it will sell far fewer copies than if it caters to a wider group that isn't looking for a grind.  That isn't to say they can't make things more difficult, which they are trying to do with water scarcity, but I wouldn't expect too much change at this point when they are pushing for gold.

Personally, if I had to work too hard to find things, I probably wouldn't play the game.  Challenge is fine but having to try forever to find enough of XYZ isn't my idea of fun.  It's like games that make ammo so scarce that you basically can't use guns except in limited situations... I usually quit playing those game after a couple of hours or never play them.  Sure, it's realistic.  But fun?  No.  That's just my own preferences and others have different preferences.

As mentioned, you can use mods to get at least close to what you are looking for.  And you don't have to double loot a POI.  I know you can but it isn't a requirement.  It is extremely rare that I will do that regardless of the loot because it just feels too gamey.
Click to expand...
This reminds me of a rock radio station that stated, "yeah, we play "Spirit of the Radio" or "Tom Sawyer" from Rush because if we constantly played "By-Tor And The Snow Dog" or "The Trees" by Rush we would lose over half of our listeners". So yeah its a fine line to please as many as you can or to cater to the few. Realistically most developers will appeal to the many or they may lose a lot of players.

Then again a game that has a great modding community can make the game appeal to the few.

I prefer fun over realism myself. If you think about realism you would have to take into consideration the ridiculous amount of Iron, Wood and stone a single person could carry. So you have a backpack that has 3 guns, 2 clips, 2 med kits and some food an water and drive the dump truck to the site where you are mining ore, collecting wood and stone and still need to make 10 trips with your dump truck. That would be realistic as far as carrying tons, literally tons of resources in your backpack. Games like S.T.A.L.K.E.R. have very limited carry capacity in your backpack to make the game less ridiculous.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Simplycasualgaming said:
As the game stands, it has left the survival horror genere and is just an arcade shooter/Tower Defense game. Death isnt a penalty. Scavaging is a joke with perks/books and double looting PoIs. At no point after day one do I have to worry about survivng and I dont even need to build a base for forever.
Click to expand...
Just play with 1 life on hardest settings.

 
The thing that I enjoy the most about 7D2D is that we can adjust the settings to decide just how much of a PITA we want things to be. I'd love to see more boss-like encounters and stuff, but I'm also okay with mods being away to add these things because there's just something really cool about seeing what the community comes up with.

BE THE CHANGE etc etc etc.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top